• Question: Is it possible to implant false memories?

    Asked by anon-188124 to Pizza Ka Yee, Paul, Nadine, Alex on 14 Nov 2018.
    • Photo: Nadine Mirza

      Nadine Mirza answered on 14 Nov 2018: last edited 14 Nov 2018 9:26 pm


      To a degree it is possible to firstly, develop false memories. This has been proven time and time again because sometimes our brain doesn’t code information correctly (we may see things that aren’t really there or miss things right in front of us). We also try to use more readily used and new information to fill in the gaps of old memories, creating potentially false memories. This can often happen with childhood memories which become biased by photos, videos and other’s stories about us like our parents anecdotes. Memories are also very strongly linked to belief systems so our memories can be become biased by our own preferences and prejudices.
      In this way, we may be able to conjure up false memories within ourselves without realising or influence others to develop false memories.
      Now, if we’re talking about implantation in a biological sense (actually changing how certain neurons are wired for example) this is still in an experimental phase that hasn’t been done on humans yet. Research is being done into this because people hope to one day use the implantation of false memories to help people forget things like trauma or to overcome PTSD. So far the closest we’ve gotten is implanting false memories in mice: https://bigthink.com/philip-perry/scientists-have-discovered-how-to-implant-false-memories

    • Photo: Alex Reid

      Alex Reid answered on 14 Nov 2018: last edited 14 Nov 2018 9:31 pm


      Crunchy, I have to hand it to you, you have asked some truly great questions! It might take us a little time to work through all of them but I must say it is really nice to see you thinking so much about psychology. To answer your question: yes you can. This can happen in a number of ways, and false memories have big ramifications for our legal system and other areas beyond psychology. However, I am going to tell you about the type of false memory I am most familiar with through sleep research. Sleep might promote some kinds of false memories because your episodic memory (that is your memory for facts, such as ‘I saw a dog yesterday’) can get integrated into your semantic memory (your memory of concepts, such as ‘what is a dog’). When this type of integration occurs false memories can arise because semantic memory will influence the original episodic memory. To give you a specific example: in some sleep experiments we could give you a list of words that have a missing word that is closely associated with the rest of them. So the word list you might see before sleep could be: nurse, bed, medical, doctor, medicine and patient. The hidden word linking all these is ‘hospital’. After learning word lists like these, it has been found that people are sometimes more likely to falsely recall the hidden critical word (hospital) following sleep. Our best understanding at the moment, as I said, is because sleep is integrating the word list with your semantic memory through memory consolidation, and as such they will all link up and activate the word ‘hospital’ in your memory when you later try and recall all the words.

    • Photo: Paul Matusz

      Paul Matusz answered on 15 Nov 2018:


      As Nadine and Alex said, it’s possible, our memories are certainly quite plastic and they change (a bit) often, with every recall, some say.
      As for true implanting of memories, it has recently been done also in a snail, one of the animal species that have been at the centre of memory research because of its qutie simple nervous system – https://www.livescience.com/62559-snail-memory-rna-transfer.html.

Comments